Found an old bug that I believe was preventing +Fishing (and more recently +Bug Hunting) from taking effect. However, it was also making experience in those activities vastly more effective than it was supposed to be.
So it'll take a while to see exactly how that shakes out. I think both activities will still be worthwhile, just require a bit more investment, but I'm open to revisiting their difficulty once things have settled.
Oh, and it's totally possible this change hilariously broke something else down the line. So obviously let me know if I blew something up.
Cheers!
Kinak