Fishing log (all fishing I've done since the revamp, all post-reset, will update):
Note: all waterlogged crates and lakebottom rocks also gave 2XP in Strength
(using old fishing pole)
1st time: filthy pistol
2: lake bluegill, filthy pistol
3: lake bluegill
4: empty cans (2)
5: lake bluegill
6: empty can
7: empty can
8: dock pike, high test fishing line, filthy pistol
(high test effect with old fishing rod)
9: old composite rod
(high test effect with old composite rod)
10: lake bluegills (2), filthy pistol, empty can
11: waterlogged crate,
12: learned Fishing skill, lake bluegills (2), dock pike
(Fishing Skill Level: Good)
13: filthy pistols (2)
14: high test fishing line, lake bluegill, empty can
15: filthy pistol, lake bluegill
16: lakebottom rock
17: lake bluegill, dock pikes (2), empty can
18: lakebottom rock
19: waterlogged crate
20: waterlogged crate
21: dock pike, lake bluegill
22: lake bluegills (2)
23: waterlogged crate
24: lakebottom rock
(Fishing Skill Level: Practiced)
25: lakebottom rock
26: lake bluegills (2), smelly pants
(old composite rod, no high test)
27: high test fishing lines (2), empty can
(old composite rod, high test)
28: empty can, dock pike, lake bluegill
29: high test fishing line, lake bluegill
30: waterlogged crate
31: smelly old pants, lake bluegill, empty can
32: lakebottom rock
33: lake bluegills (3), high test fishing line
34: high test fishing lines (2), lake bluegills (2)
35: lake bluegills (3), dock pike
36: lake bluegills (2), empty can, high test fishing line
37: lakebottom rock
38: lake bluegills (2), filthy pistol, dock pike