I got this instead for hobo outfit (+ mislit mask and dragon twin statuette):
She chuckles a little at your costume. "Maybe this makes me a terrible person, but we've got a dozen people here with zombie costumes and a dozen people with corpse costumes. I cannot tell the difference, but here's some candy."
And the text for doctor outfit had something about "can't go wrong with fake blood", but I didn't notice it was different from what wiki says, so I didn't copy it.
Also, the extra candy I get for "unknown reason" is peanut butter candy, not pumpkin lollipops.
ETA: well. not *always* lollipops. Also, candy eyeball and candy corn.